I would like to start this post with an apology. This is by no means an attempt to justify my actions or excuse them. Catfishing is manipulative, insensitive and cowardly. I must have started to tell this story a hundred times and each time I have found it too painful, too ashamed by my own actions. There is no excuse for catfishing. I’m yet to hear a good one. This post isn’t here to serve as a defence of catfishing, simply to lay all the cards on the table. To the people who were involved, I am deeply sorry. I’m sure you are all thriving now and tell this story to your friends who all comment how crazy I am and what a massive bitch I must be. I was thirteen at the time and I’ve done a lot of growing up since then. But yes, I think I agree that thirteen year old me was a crazy bitch.
I was recently reading an article about a lady who catfished someone she knew: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/jul/15/gayle-newland-retrial
The story is absolutely ludicrous. “You couldn’t make it up” as people love to say. I wasn’t as surprised as I should have been at the awful ordeal because I’ve witnessed it firsthand. I hate to say it, but I was surprised that no one was more concerned for Gayle. That’s the same as saying “but what about Peter Sutcliffe? He must’ve been feeling some pretty strong emotions otherwise he wouldn’t have bothered killing all those women?”. I realised this was because I was feeling a strong sense of sympathy. The day all my lies unravelled around me will be one I never forget.
My mum called me up to her bedroom. It was late, the curtains were drawn and she was ironing, leaving the strong steamy smell in the air. I dragged myself away from the computer downstairs, oblivious to the words she was about to strike me with.
“I’ve just had P’s mum on the phone,” she said, running the iron over a white t-shirt, “she asked me if I knew what ward Stephen is on. Apparently I’ve been visiting him in hospital.”
I froze. She continued.
“I told her I’ve never even met Stephen. She said apparently he’s in hospital dying of cancer and P is absolutely beside herself. She said you said we’ve been going to visit him.”
“Oh,” I mustered, feeling blank.
“Do you know anything about this?”
“I mean, I knew he was in hospital,” I lied.
“Well,” she folded the t-shirt, “I’ve certainly never been to see him. I don’t even know him. She’s going to speak to P now.” She dropped the folded t-shirt onto a pile on a chair beside her with a small fabric clap. “I told her I’d speak to you and ask if you knew anything.”
Expressionless, I returned to the computer. The irony being that for once I was logged onto my own account and was enjoying life being me, playing Minesweeper Flags with an old boyfriend of mine. I told him I had to go.
What followed felt like some sort of civil lawsuit. Overnight I had transformed from being surrounded by – both real and fake – friends to a social pariah. Rooms went immediately quiet whenever I walked in, pointed whispers and menacing laughter followed me as I tried my best to forget what everyone was so intensely interested in. I hadn’t lied to one person, I’d lied to most people.
P’s father was a no one in the judicial system. A male chauvinist who believed whatever he said must be true because he had said it. You may think that my dislike of this man is bias because he was head of the investigation but I can tell you he was universally ill-thought of. Even by his own daughter. He immediately called my mum again, feeling the matter now warranted his attention. He had a long, bossy conversation with her where he told her that he was thinking of going to the police but wanted to have a sit down conversation with us both first. My mum told him that tomorrow we are going to Florida for two weeks and that it would have to wait until we came back. What should have been a child’s dream holiday felt like an anxiety nightmare. I would spend hours in my room, thinking of justifications and reasons, cringing at all the things I had said to all the people who for now were under the impression it was me. We returned from ‘the happiest place on Earth’ and P’s father was on the phone the following day, my mum, also finding him repugnant, told him we had just come back from across the Atlantic and we were jet-lagged and that she would be in touch soon. He wasted no time in telling her that he had called some of the fake phone numbers I had given out and had explained to the call’s recipient that their number had been used in a case where someone has been grooming children. “They said they will be very co-operative, that they were innocent,” he proudly explained, “but they’ve never heard of Stephen or Chris.”
He got his meeting. I dare say it wasn’t at all what he had been hoping for. When I told him I didn’t have the answers he was looking for, on trial in his cluttered living room with my mum, P and P’s mum present, he began a rather smug assault on my character. “Well,” a smug smirk curling onto his fleshy face, “I have to say, I don’t really understand why you’re not more upset about this, S. If someone was accusing me of these things then I think I would be a bit more…” he circled his hands as he looked for his words, “bothered.” I was bothered. I had thought of nothing else since. Everything I had known for the past year was coming to a screeching crash, thousands of angry bystanders looking on, cheering as the champion witch hunter paraded my head around on a stick.
I promised myself I would be honest and frank with this story. I owe it to all the people I lied to. I had grown genuinely attached to the people that Stephen and Chris had allowed me to be friends with and I wanted it to come to an end. I had woven two likeable teenage heart throbs. They were accessible, unoffencive, sensitive, complimentary, interested. The plan had never been trick anyone into a romantic relationship. If I had filled in a form before entering the venture, the box which asked: will you be using this platform for romance purposes? I would have firmly ticked ‘no’. So, what happened? How did two teenage girls end up in tears, heartbroken and angry?
I wish I knew.
It’s something I still think about. Sometimes I’ll be laying in bed or having a bath, I’ll squint and ask myself: “what happened?”. Even seventeen years later, I still can’t work it out. There was no particular excitement or high that I had from lying, no power trip, no thrill. I didn’t think I was better or smarter than them. I certainly was aware that I didn’t feel the way my characters felt. So, what was it?
“She’s a very placid person,” my mum said, coming to my rescue, “she’s always been very calm.”
“Do you understand, S,” P’s father continued, “how serious this is? We could be dealing with paedophiles?” I told him I understood. “You don’t have anything to say?” I told him I didn’t. “Well,” he sat up in his old fabric sofa, “then I guess I have no choice but to call the Police.” The room was silent and tense. We had been in the interrogation for about forty minutes. Everyone knew it was me. P’s dad had been hoping to be the hero and emerge victorious. Picturing himself opening phone calls with a big sigh and saying to the other parents, “yep, I got her.” Instead, I blinked at the floor and nodded, a slow and heavy nod. P’s father, sensing that we were about to be adjourned, took one more swipe at me. “I think it’s you, S,” he said, raising his voice slightly, “I think you are behind all of this.” He waited for me to engage, to erupt in tears and through the garbled mess of my distress cry, “I did it! It was me, I did it, OK?”. Instead, I nodded, looked at him for a long pause and then shrugged. He walked us to the door, repeating several times that he was going to phone the Police now. My mum told him that they would know where to find us.
We sat in the car. Mum had stuck up for me several times and I felt like she was on my side. She was but she didn’t believe me. I was chatty for the first time that day, trying to explain to my technophobe mother how a virus in the computer could make our computer IP address show up, given that Stephen and Chris had sent me so much stuff over the internet. “That’s not true,” she said, buckling her seatbelt. I sat back in the passenger seat. I was defeated.
We got home and I immediately called my mum upstairs to my room. I was tearful, remorseful and everything P’s dad’s wet dream had hoped I would be. I told her I did it to make friends. I hadn’t carried any friends forward from primary school and inventing these characters had allowed me to get to know everyone. It was easier to talk to people I didn’t know as someone else because I (me) had nothing to lose. So what if they didn’t like Stephen? Real me hadn’t lost anything, only a fictional person who was incapable of having sleepless nights over a conversation had. What had this new power given me? Freedom. I was no longer shackled by social anxiety or lack of confidence. What I found out about myself was that I was funny, people thought I was charming…or rather, the people that I was the puppet master of were. I would get to know people as Stephen and then, when they liked me, I would say: “My friend, S, goes to your school, do you know her?”. They would say they knew of me but didn’t know me. I’d tell them how nice I am. What felt like overnight, I gained an abundance of friends. Not just any friends, the popular kids who up until now hadn’t even spared me a thought other than to say something juvenile or unkind. Now I had a cool, confident friend like Stephen, I was one of them. I wept as I explained this to my mum who rubbed my knee as I recounted how I had come to realise that I didn’t need my fake friends anymore. The cancer story had been an out. I wanted Stephen gone. His death seemed the fastest way out and it would be final. I couldn’t go back to him, he would be finished. Had I considered how upset people would be? Yes and no. I knew they would be sad but sadness is temporary…right? She didn’t say anything. I told her I was really sorry. I told her I knew everyone was going to be angry with me. She said I was right but they were allowed to be angry. I told her I know they are. With a weighty sigh, she left my side and went to make P’s dad’s day. It was a bright August day, I sat in the sun that beamed through the window of my attic room. Everything was eerily cheerful and calm. My mum returned and told me that P’s dad had playfully called me a banana. I suspect she was being kind. She left and I sat in silence, knowing that outside the apocalypse was happening. Landlines were ringing, people were gasping, sighing with relief and anger. It wasn’t long before my mum was back in my room, extending the phone to me. P wanted to talk. It’s hard to describe how I felt and I remember very little of our conversation. I had entered a kind of trance. It’s the sort of blank space I expect I would be in if I found myself faced with an approaching ball of fire. The pain is inevitable, you’ve just got to wait for it.
“I would have been your friend,” P said calmly. I didn’t believe her. I wanted to tell her I was cripplingly shy and we would never have spoken but I acknowledged her instead. Like her father, I expect she had been wanting more than the void of where her friend once was. The call ended and I returned to silence. My mum returned with the landline and told me it was my (now ex) friend, F.
F was the most popular girl in our school. She had large friendship groups, a sparkling sense of humour and she could make you feel like you were the only friend that mattered to her. I had never aspired to being her friend but somehow along the way it had happened. The problem was F was the only one who more consistently preferred made-up Chris to me. She would talk candidly to Chris about home life, fears, secrets, loves and hates, about her friends, who annoyed her and why. I had become close to F but I could never get her to open up in the same way as she did to Chris. Why? Because she loved him.
Now, this next part will sound unrelatable and cruel, but as promised, it’s the genuine truth. Did I think entering a virtual relationship with F was wrong? Yes. Was saying I love you too far? Yes, it was. Was I aware of this at the time? I think I was, yes. Then why didn’t it stop? I wasn’t in love with her. I said things to her I didn’t mean. Even as a supportive friend, I didn’t think she was beautiful like the boys at our school did. I wasn’t jealous, I just didn’t think it. It comes down to the quest of ultimately being liked. If someone is in a relationship with you then chances are you are doing a pretty good job of making them like you. The fact that “you” are enough, when you’ve been an outcast for most of your life, is hugely reassuring. Once again, I failed to recognise the true gravity of the situation. That what I was doing, albeit not maliciously, was going to leave someone I really cared about feeling hurt and upset.
A few months prior to this phone call, it had dawned on me that I needed to ‘shut down’ Chris more than I did Stephen. Stephen barely logged on anymore but I was becoming Chris everyday. I liked F and I respected her. Yes, she didn’t like me as much as she liked Chris but the reasons why were slowly revealing to me as I was growing slightly older, maturing. I didn’t need to kill Chris. In my naivety, I thought that telling her that it wasn’t working out was going to be the end of it. Sure, she’d hate Chris but I’d be there and soon we would all be friends in a Chrisless world. Of course, that isn’t what happened. There I was with F in the medical room at school, holding one hand with P holding the other. F had taken the news worse than expected and was now suffering public panic attacks. Segregated away from the wide eyes of our peers, we sat silent in the clinically bright white room, listening to our friend’s frantic breathing. She was sent home. In a panic, I reignited the relationship and sat begrudgingly having empty conversations with someone I couldn’t stand. Not F, but Chris.
“I warn you,” my mum mouthed to me, holding the phone to her chest, “she’s very upset.” I nodded and accepted the phone from her. My mum left the room. “Do you know,” F said through her raspy tears, “how much of our lives have been wasted?” In a dulled, painless voice I told her I did and I was sorry. “I’ve spent a year with someone when I could have been with someone else!” I apologised again. “Everyone,” she drew in a large snotty nasal breath, “is going to think that we are idiots because of you!” I couldn’t think of anything to say other than to keep repeating how sorry I was. “When I was sat in the medical room that day, you wouldn’t even look at me!” I remember not agreeing with this. I had been looking at her, in fact, I’d been staring. I’d never seen someone having a panic attack before and it was frightening. I knew better than to say that though, instead I apologised again. I can’t remember how to call ended but I know it was short and she more than likely hung up on me. I don’t think we ever spoke again.
Seventeen years later, as I lay in the bath reading the article above, I asked myself a lot of questions. I don’t think what I did was particularly clever. Fooling all those people doesn’t make me feel like some kind of genius or master manipulator. It makes me feel incredibly sad and very small. I had attempted to bypass my personality, my flaws, and lazily create meaningful friendships. What I ended up doing was putting everything I didn’t like about myself, all the bad pieces of my personality, on public display when I was burned at the stake. I’ve never spoken to anyone about what happened despite it being public knowledge. As far as I can find, Gayle Newland and other famed catfish, Gemma Barker, have never spoken their side of the story either. I can tell the story but I don’t think I will ever be able to explain it. There will be people out there, other outsiders, other people who craved social acceptance, that would see this and think that they would never have resorted to this. But I guess that’s like saying there are people out there without bread who wouldn’t resort to stealing. People are different.
I’m thirty now. I’m not hugely popular but I’m also not desperately lonely. The people that I know now know the real me. Whilst writing this, I’ve tried to put myself in touch with the thirteen year old me that did these things and I’m almost pleased to say I can’t reach her. I know she’s not a monster, she’s not heartless and she’s not evil. She’s someone who talks to herself, she can make herself laugh and wants nothing more than to have other people in her life she can make laugh too. Her mind is filled with a whole cast of imaginary friends who come alive in her bedroom, two of which escaped into the real world.
I still have the wild imagination but it’s rarely seen in public. I’ve learnt to enjoy their idea but not their presence. I can’t remember when I stopped impulsively lying but it was some point in my mid to late twenties. I guess it becomes exhausting. It’s cliche but the truth really does set you free. I’ve found greater joy in telling the truth than I ever did from lying. That thirteen year old me in this story struggled for the next few years, living in the prison of my actions. I guess I deserved it. P and F are both fine, I haven’t seen anything about either of them for a long time but ones married and the other went to university. P’s dad did, however, pass away a few years ago. He might not come across very well in this story (or perhaps he does) but he was a man trying to do right by his daughter.
There might not be any answers in here but it’s good to finally get it all down. I’m genuinely sorry to all those that were involved. From the bottom of my heart, it was disgusting and I was wrong. There really is no good reason to catfish.